| Winners | Year Sort ascending | Rating | Format |
|---|---|---|---|
| William E. Lamble, Jr. | 1950 | class a | hardball |
| William E. Lamble, Jr. | 1949 | class a | hardball |
| William E. Lamble, Jr. | 1948 | class a | hardball |
| William E. Lamble, Jr. | 1947 | class a | hardball |
| Frank P. Gould (MC) | 1946 | class a | hardball |
| William E. Lamble, Jr. | 1945 | class a | hardball |
| Frank P. Gould (MC) | 1944 | class a | hardball |
| H. L. Burkheimer (BAC) | 1943 | class a | hardball |
| H. L. Burkheimer (BAC) | 1942 | class a | hardball |
| H. L. Burkheimer (BAC) | 1941 | class a | hardball |
| James J. Lacy, Sr. (BAC) | 1940 | class a | hardball |
