| Winners | Year Sort ascending | Rating | Format |
|---|---|---|---|
| James J. Lacy, Sr. (BAC) | 1940 | class a | hardball |
| F. G. Gerald (BAC) | 1939 | class a | hardball |
| H. B. Commings (BAC) | 1938 | class a | hardball |
| H. B. Commings (BAC) | 1937 | class a | hardball |
| H. B. Commings (BAC) | 1936 | class a | hardball |
| W. H. Baugher (BAC) | 1935 | class a | hardball |
| W. H. Baugher (BAC) | 1934 | class a | hardball |
| W. H. Baugher (BAC) | 1933 | class a | hardball |
| W. H. Baugher (BAC) | 1932 | class a | hardball |
| W. H. Baugher (BAC) | 1931 | class a | hardball |
| W. H. Baugher (BAC) | 1930 | class a | hardball |
